Unit 1
Disciplined Thinking
Big question
Can I find the assumptions inside my own thinking and revise my position honestly?
Overview
Before studying anyone else's arguments, students turn the lens on their own minds. They learn to surface the assumptions they never chose, tell a perspective apart from a position, and hold a belief firmly while staying honestly open to changing it. The unit closes with a bias audit of their own earlier work.
The unit project is the Assumption Audit Portfolio. The Teacher Edition paces the unit over twenty six sessions, about nine weeks of three forty minute periods, and each lesson pairs the reader with practice in words, reading, thinking, a Historian's Lab skill, and a short Historian's Notebook entry.
The Islamic lens draws on dhann, tafakkur, and muhasaba: the difference between conjecture and certainty, careful reflection, and honest self accounting.
Chapters
- 01
What Is an Assumption?
How does an unexamined assumption quietly decide which evidence we accept?
- 02
Perspective and Position
If nobody thinks from nowhere, how do we name our own standpoint and still hold a position honestly?
- 03
Intellectual Humility
What does humility actually require, and how is revising different from capitulating?
- 04
The Bias Audit
How do we turn every tool of this unit on our own argument and audit it fairly?
Components
- Workbook
- Teacher's Guide
- Activity Pages
Themes
- Islamic lens: Dhann, tafakkur, and muhasaba
Standards
| Framework | Code | Description |
|---|---|---|
| C3 Framework | D2.Civ.10.3-5 | Identify the beliefs, experiences, perspectives, and values that underlie decisions on civic issues. |
| C3 Framework | D2.His.4.3-5 | Explain why people in the same period differed in their perspectives. |
| C3 Framework | D4.4.3-5 | Critique arguments. |
| Common Core | RI.5.1, RI.5.7 | Quote accurately from the text and draw on charts and diagrams. Practiced in every Reading Check. |
| Common Core | L.5.4a, L.5.6 | Use context clues and grade appropriate academic vocabulary from the chapter glossaries. |
| Common Core | W.5.1, W.5.2, W.5.10 | Write opinions and explanations, with a short Historian's Notebook entry in every lesson. |
| Common Core | SL.5.1 | Engage in collaborative discussions, through partner talks and games. |
Inside the unit
Four parts
- 01
The Student Workbook
The unit's chapters and short lessons, with the reading, activity boxes, and an Islamic lens.
- 02
The Teacher Guide
One for every unit, written against the workbook, so page references, activity box names, and answer keys match.
- 03
The Unit Project
Every unit ends in a project that pulls the chapters together, such as an argument brief, a museum exhibit, a portfolio, an atlas, or a panel.
- 04
Activity Pages
A printable pack of activity pages at the back of each workbook, for partner work and projects.
